Top Insurance Stocks to Consider: Which Insurance Stocks Should You Choose for 2024

Curious about which insurance stocks should you choose for 2024?

We’ve analyzed and picked leading options like Oscar Health (OSCR), UnitedHealth Group, and Prudential Financial, likely to shine in the coming year due to their robust market positions and growth potential.

Introduction

The world of insurance, including mortgage insurance, may not immediately strike one as a hotbed of excitement, yet it is a sphere where the astute investor can find significant value. Insurance stocks represent companies that provide pivotal services to both businesses and individuals, generating revenue through the premiums collected from insurance policies. This sector is unique in its capacity to create wealth by employing the concept of ‘float’—the pooling of premiums to be reinvested for returns.

These stocks often mirror the ebb and flow of the broader economic cycle, presenting opportunities for discerning investors to capitalize on their cyclical behavior. As we step into the second half of 2024, our focus sharpens on identifying the cream of the crop within this industry. From specialty insurers to giants in life and health insurance, we will dissect the top picks that should be on your radar.

Understanding Insurance Stocks

When we speak of insurance stocks, we refer to the stalwarts that underpin the insurance industry. These companies not only sell health insurance but provide a safety net across various domains, from property and casualty to life insurance. At the core of the insurance business lies the strategy of achieving underwriting profit—assessing risk to ensure that premiums outpace claims and associated expenses.

Investors must navigate this terrain with insight, distinguishing between insurers who cater to different needs and exhibit diverse financial dynamics. While health insurers focus on health plans and managing the cost of care, a property and casualty insurer covers property damage and liability protection. It is this diversity that allows the insurance industry to offer a stock advisor service that has often seen stock advisor returns outpace the stock market.

The Best Insurance Stocks for 2024

As investors map out their strategies for the year, a trio of insurance companies stands out for their potential to contribute both stability and growth to portfolios. These three insurance stocks - Progressive Corporation (PGR), UnitedHealth Group, and Prudential Financial - are unlike most insurance companies, as they have each carved their own niches within the vast insurance landscape, offering a range of insurance products that have consistently piqued the interest of stock advisors and investors alike.

Progressive Corporation (PGR)

Progressive Corporation is widely known in the insurance industry for its' innovative approach (just to mention usage-based insurance program Snapshot) and robust financial performance. Company is one of the largest car insurers in US - and this fact is exacetly what's standing behind its strong market presence and brand recognition.

The main reason to invest in Progressive's stock is its solid financial performance.; PGR has demonstrated consistent revenue and earnings growth over past years, reflecting its ability to successfully manage risk and capitalize on market opportunities. What's more, company has an attractive dividend policy enriched by shareholder-friendly approach that may be interesting from the point of view of income-seeking investors.

Investing in PGR's stock simply means exposure to the resilient and growing insurance industry. The company's ability to navigate regulatory challenges and leverage technological advancements makes it a perfect choice for those seeking for both growth, as well as stability.

UnitedHealth Group (UNH)

UnitedHealth Group takes center stage as a leading health insurer, offering an array of health plans that serve as a reliable indicator of its robust position in the market. As the largest of health insurers, its extensive revenue streams and growth prospects make it a compelling choice for investors looking to buy stock in the health insurance sector.

The company’s influence extends across the healthcare landscape, where it competes with other big names like Aetna and CIGNA Corp, while also selling health insurance that meets the evolving needs of consumers. UnitedHealth Group’s stock advisor returns reflect the company’s capacity to navigate the complexities of the insurance business and emerge as a top insurance stock to buy.

Importantly, UNH is not standing still - the company is undertaking a number of activities aimed at gaining new customers and breaking into the insurance company market. It recently implemented the UnitedHealthcare Catalyst program in Owensboro, KY, aimed at providing health outcomes for patients struggling with type 2 diabetes on a daily basis.

Of course, these aren't the only news on the company's growth horizon - so it's worth keeping a close eye on its further developments.

Prudential Financial (PRU)

Prudential Financial’s reputation as one of the largest life insurers is well-earned. Here are some key facts about the company:

• It has a global reach, operating in key markets in Asia, the UK, and the United States.
• It has a strong balance sheet, which speaks to its financial strength.

Despite facing a downturn in its stock price in recent years, Prudential Financial has demonstrated resilience, recovering and maintaining a strong presence in the market. With over $320 billion in bonds, net premiums written, and a net equity above $28 billion, the company’s financial health positions it as a reliable insurance stock for investors seeking life insurance options with potential for growth.

Emerging Opportunities in Health Insurance Stocks

The US healthcare market is in the throes of a transformative period, with companies like Elevance Health, Oscar Health, and CVS Health at the forefront of this evolution. These health insurers are seizing the moment, capitalizing on the shift from traditional fee-for-service models to value-based care, and leveraging technology to offer more personalized and efficient health care solutions.

Elevance Health (ELV)

Elevance Health, formerly known as Anthem, stands out as a beacon of innovation within the health insurance industry. Poised to reap the benefits of the shift towards value-based care, Elevance Health offers comprehensive health plans, including Medicare Advantage, which cater to the growing demand for high-quality healthcare coverage.

As a reliable indicator of the health insurance sector’s potential, Elevance Health’s focus on value-driven healthcare models promises to deliver enhanced care outcomes for its members and drive growth for investors. The company’s strategic position within the market makes it a particularly interesting proposition for those seeking to invest in health stocks with a forward-thinking approach.

Oscar Health (OSCR)

In the quest for a more user-friendly health insurance experience, Oscar Health emerges as a pioneer with its tech-driven approach. By simplifying the complexities of health insurance, Oscar Health’s platform is designed to guide consumers to quality and affordable care, including offering Medicare Advantage plans to the aging population.

The company’s recent financial performance underscores its strategic initiatives, with notable improvements in premium earnings and a reduction in net losses—evidence of a disciplined pricing strategy and operational efficiency. Oscar Health’s commitment to technological innovation and customer-centric care positions it as a prominent player in the evolving landscape of health insurance stocks.

Specialty Insurers with High Potential

Venturing beyond the mainstream, specialty insurers like Markel Corporation and Allianz SE serve niche markets with unique and oftentimes high-risk insurance products. These specialty insurers command higher premiums and, as a result, hold the promise of delivering greater returns for those willing to delve into less-trodden paths within the insurance sector.

Markel Corporation (MKL)

Markel Corporation is a company that embodies the very essence of specialty insurance, with a unique ‘Markel Style’ investment philosophy that has captivated the business world. Renowned for its innovative insurance products, Markel addresses specialized risks that often go unnoticed by larger insurers, carving out a niche that has the potential to produce monster returns. An example of this type of specialized product could be the Markel Play service, which will serve as a comprehensive insurance product tailored to the sports, fitness and recreation sectors.

The company’s growth trajectory, punctuated by a 35% increase in operating income, is a testament to its successful diversification and focus on high-margin businesses. Investors looking for companies that not only insure but also invest wisely should find Markel’s strategy and financial performance compelling reasons to consider adding MKL to their stock picks.

Allianz SE (ALV.DE)

Allianz SE’s global presence and prowess in asset management make it a standout among insurance stocks. With operations spanning over 70 countries and managing assets worth upwards of EUR 2.5 trillion, Allianz SE is a behemoth in the insurance world. This company serves a wide array of insurance needs, from life insurance to property and casualty ensuring a diversified and resilient portfolio.

These standard solutions and offerings, although best known among the typical Smiths, do not exclude the company from the ranks of specialty insurers - suffice it to mention that Allianz's global operations also include lesser-known services such as fine art insurance, or wine and sprits insurance.

What makes Allianz particularly attractive to income-focused investors is its reputation for steady dividend payouts, a factor that adds an extra layer of allure to this insurance stock. With a combined ratio that reflects its efficiency and a track record spanning the past year and beyond, Allianz SE represents a solid option for those seeking a blend of stability and potential growth in the insurance industry.

Why Insurance Stocks Are Recession-Resistant

The resilience of insurance stocks during economic downturns is a key consideration for investors seeking recession-resistant business models. Insurance companies have historically shown an ability to weather financial storms, maintaining demand for their essential services even when other sectors falter.

Furthermore, the conservative investment strategies employed by insurers, which prioritize security over high yields, play a pivotal role in their ability to provide stability to investors.

Summary

Drawing together the threads of our exploration, it is evident that insurance stocks hold a unique position in the investment landscape. With the ability to provide a buffer against economic volatility and a track record for consistent performance, these stocks offer an attractive proposition for investors in 2024. The companies highlighted in this discussion, from industry titans to emerging players and niche specialists, comprise a portfolio of opportunities that balance risk with potential rewards.

Let this exposition serve as a springboard for your investment decisions, encouraging a deeper dive into the insurance sector. Whether you’re drawn to the stability of long-established players or the dynamism of up-and-coming health insurers, the insights provided here aim to guide you towards informed, strategic choices that resonate with your financial goals.

Psst... Are you impressed with the clarity of the table in the above screenshot? This is nothing but our flagship functionality, which is fundamental scoring! Stock analysis has never been simpler than with this feature - you can freely customize chosen stocks, selected metrics and thus avoid cognitive biases, relying only on pure data, not market rumors!

‍